Current:Home > ScamsMaine Town Wins Round in Tar Sands Oil Battle With Industry -Aspire Capital Guides
Maine Town Wins Round in Tar Sands Oil Battle With Industry
View
Date:2025-04-16 12:27:07
SOUTH PORTLAND, Maine—A federal judge has handed a win to South Portland, Maine over a pipeline company that wants to send tar sands oil through the city, a proposal seen as opening a path for Canada’s crude to reach the East Coast for export.
But the fight is not over. A federal district court judge dismissed on Dec. 29 all but one of the company’s claims against the city. The ruling still leaves open a key question: whether the city is violating the U.S. Constitution by blocking the project.
At the heart of the lawsuit is the question of local control and what—if anything—a community can do to block an unwanted energy project.
The outcome could influence similar lawsuits elsewhere. When the Portland Pipe Line Corporation (PPLC) sued this small coastal city in 2015, it had some powerful allies, including the American Petroleum Institute, whose members include most major oil and gas companies.
The industry argued that a local ordinance prohibiting the export of heavy crude from South Portland’s harbor is unconstitutional. That ordinance essentially stopped in its tracks PPLC’s plans to reverse an existing pipeline and start piping tar sands oil from Canada to Maine, where it could be shipped to international markets.
“It’s a great decision,” said Sean Mahoney, of the Conservation Law Foundation, who has advised the city. “They won on 8 out of 9 counts—but they’ve got a big kahuna count left.”
What’s left to decide is whether the ordinance violates the federal commerce clause—an authority granted by the Constitution, which allows Congress to regulate interstate commerce. The company’s argument is that local authorities do not have the ability to regulate interstate trade.
That issue will likely be taken up in a trial later this year.
Portland Pipe Line Corporation has been developing plans to reverse the flow direction of its Portland-Montreal Pipeline for nearly a decade. The pipeline currently brings conventional oil from South Portland to Montreal, but since production of tar sands oil in Canada ramped up, the need for oil to be delivered from Maine to Quebec has all but disappeared, along with PPLC’s business model.
Since getting wind of the company’s plans 2013, a local grassroots effort led by the group Protect South Portland has fought the reversal, arguing it would increase air pollution. The reversal would call for the construction of a pair of 70-foot high smokestacks that would burn off volatile organic compounds from the oil before loading it into tankers.
After a ballot initiative to block the project failed— a measure that API and oil companies spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to defeat—the City Council passed an ordinance in 2014. Called the Clear Skies Ordinance, it zeroed in on air pollution concerns from the project.
The lawsuit swiftly followed the ordinance’s passage, and a lengthy—and expensive—legal process ensued. As of August 2017, the city had spent $1.1 million dollars to defend the ordinance. South Portland’s operating budget is $32.6 million.
Following earlier decisions that were not in the city’s favor, the judge’s ruling came as a surprise to supporters of the ordinance. The decision dismissed claims by the company that several federal laws preempt local law.
“Immediately I felt some relief,” said Rachel Burger, the co-founder and president of Protect South Portland. “Suddenly it’s like, oh, we might prevail.”
The company said it will continue its fight against the ordinance.
“While we are disappointed with aspects of the judge’s decision, our claim under the Commerce Clause remains to be decided,” attorney Jim Merrill, who represents PPLC, said in a statement. “Portland Montreal Pipe Line will vigorously continue its challenge of the ordinance.”
South Portland City Manager Scott Morelli said the city was pleased with the judge’s rulings and will continue to defend the ordinance. “The city looks forward to the opportunity to resolve the remaining issues in its favor,” he said.
It could be a long haul. No matter the outcome of the trial, both sides are expected to appeal, and the case could wind up in the U.S. Supreme Court.
veryGood! (65)
Related
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
- Arkansas State Police probe death of woman found after officer
- Costco membership growth 'robust,' even amid fee increase: What to know about earnings release
- Biden administration makes final diplomatic push for stability across a turbulent Mideast
- Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
- The FBI should have done more to collect intelligence before the Capitol riot, watchdog finds
- NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
- Hackers hit Rhode Island benefits system in major cyberattack. Personal data could be released soon
Ranking
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- South Korean president's party divided over defiant martial law speech
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Jamie Foxx gets stitches after a glass is thrown at him during dinner in Beverly Hills
- South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
- Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
- A White House order claims to end 'censorship.' What does that mean?
- South Korean president's party divided over defiant martial law speech
Recommendation
Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
Stamford Road collision sends motorcyclist flying; driver arrested
NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
McConnell absent from Senate on Thursday as he recovers from fall in Capitol
Meet the volunteers risking their lives to deliver Christmas gifts to children in Haiti
Nearly half of US teens are online ‘constantly,’ Pew report finds
Intellectuals vs. The Internet